As we navigate through the complexities of building skill-based communities, Michael Sandel's "The Tyranny of Merit" has offered profound insights, challenging us to reconsider the role of meritocracy in our society. Sandel's book delves into the divisive nature of meritocracy, particularly in an age where success is often attributed to personal achievement, overshadowing the role of luck and the systemic advantages that benefit the already fortunate.
Sandel argues that this meritocratic viewpoint has fueled societal polarization, creating a divide between winners and losers. This, in turn, has led to a brewing resentment and distrust among those who feel left behind by a system that values merit above all else. His work emphasizes the need for a more inclusive understanding of success, one that acknowledges the role of luck and fosters an ethic of humility and solidarity.
In our journey to draft the protocol for a skill-based community, we faced dilemmas directly related to these insights. While establishing parameters like per-hour rates and skill levels to streamline onboarding and project allocation, we encountered pushback. Sandel's book was recommended to understand the nuances better.
One crucial takeaway from "The Tyranny of Merit" is the necessity of balancing merit with accessibility. While meritocracy in itself is not inherently flawed, as Jordan Peterson points out with the example of selecting a heart surgeon, there's a dire need to improve access for all. This understanding led us to suggest labor-based and capital-based access to communities. Those unable to pay can contribute through work, while those short on time can gain access via payment. This approach aligns with Sandel's vision of a more inclusive society, where merit is balanced with opportunities for all.
Moreover, Sandel's ideas have influenced our approach to community engagement. Initiatives like QuantumComputingIndia's #Quantum30, a 30-day learning challenge, underscore the importance of motivation beyond just merit. By incorporating points for consistency, reflections, and daily learning, we aim to encourage participation and growth, reflecting the ethos that everyone has something valuable to contribute, regardless of their starting point.
In summary, Michael Sandel's "The Tyranny of Merit" does not outright dismiss meritocracy but calls for its reevaluation in light of fairness and equal opportunity. It reminds us that while merit is essential, it must be coupled with systems that ensure everyone has the chance to succeed. This philosophy is deeply embedded in our DAOcommons protocol, advocating for a balance of merit and opportunity, reflecting a commitment to the common good.
As we continue to build and refine our skill-based communities, we keep these lessons at the forefront, striving to create a space where merit and opportunity coexist harmoniously, fostering a more equitable and inclusive environment for all.